Spot the Splurge: Which Designer Shoe Is Hiding Here?

Five pairs, five lookalikes, one splurge in each. Look closely, make your call and see if your eye is as sharp as your taste.

We compare dupes side by side from listings and photos. Some links earn us a small commission at no cost to you; it never decides what we pick. How that works.

Welcome to the game. Each round shows two shoes with brands and prices hidden. Look closely, then tap the one you think is the splurge. This week is all about shoes: clogs, sandals and boots, from cozy to sleek. Easy rounds first, tricky ones last.

Round 1 of 5

Which one is the splurge?

Hint Check the footbed and the strap hardware.

Just show me the answer

The splurge · Option B

Birkenstock Boston Soft Footbed Suede Leather Clog

$169.95

The dupe · Option A

ODOLY Genuine Suede Clogs for Women Men Comfort Cork Footbed Potato Shoes

$25.64 Save 85%

The splurge is the Birkenstock Boston Soft Footbed Suede Clog, known for its contoured cork-latex footbed with an added foam layer. The ODOLY clog gets close with a taupe upper, an adjustable metal-buckle strap and a cork footbed with a deep heel cup, going by its listing. The tradeoff is build: the suede thickness, finishing and footbed are unlikely to match the original's.

Round 2 of 5

Which one is the splurge?

Hint Study the cutouts in the strap.

Just show me the answer

The splurge · Option A

Hermes Oran Sandal

$900

The dupe · Option B

Classic H-Band Flats Sandals

$29.99 Save 97%

The splurge is the Hermès Oran Sandal, made from Box calfskin on a natural leather sole. The AprCoco H-Band copies the white H-shaped strap and flat slip-on shape, but its listing says faux leather, a rubber sole and a memory foam insole. Its toe also looks more squared with a raised footbed edge, and similar looks don't tell us how it holds up over time.

Round 3 of 5

Which one is the splurge?

Hint Check the metal bar at the top of the shaft.

Just show me the answer

The splurge · Option A

Givenchy Shark Pinch Ankle Boots

$2,120

The dupe · Option B

Goolita Fold Over Boots For Women

$59 Save 97%

The splurge is the Givenchy Shark Pinch Ankle Boot, with a taller, more structured collar and an engraved gold bar. The Goolita boot matches the fold-over shaft, black strap and gold bar, but its bar looks longer and slimmer with no engraving visible, and the top is more open with a visible lining. The tradeoff is material: the listing doesn't state one, and it's likely synthetic rather than calfskin.

Round 4 of 5

Which one is the splurge?

Hint Follow the seam around the front of the ankle.

Just show me the answer

The splurge · Option A

Hermes Jumping Shorter Boot

$3,500

The dupe · Option B

YDN Classic Round Toe Knee High Boots

$110 Save 97%

The splurge is the Hermès Jumping Shorter Boot, made from Box calfskin and topped with its famous palladium Kelly buckle strap. The YDN boot nails the glossy black shaft, rounded toe and stitched U-shaped ankle panel. The tradeoff is that no buckle strap shows in the photo, which is the original's best-known feature, and the upper appears to be synthetic.

Round 5 of 5

Which one is the splurge?

Hint Watch how the shaft folds and catches the light.

Just show me the answer

The splurge · Option A

Givenchy Shark Pinch Boots

$2,550

The dupe · Option B

Goolita Fold Over Knee High Boots

$63 Save 98%

The splurge is the Givenchy Shark Pinch Boot, with a sculpted calfskin shaft and a gold pinch bar engraved with the brand name. The Goolita fold-over boot has the same sleek, glossy black tube and folded cuff, but its photo only shows the shaft, so the gold hardware isn't confirmed. The tradeoff is structure: its folds may look softer and wrinklier, and the material isn't stated, likely synthetic.

How to shop this look

  • Hardware gives a lot away: look for crisp engraving, weight and finish on buckles and bars.
  • Materials read differently: real leather and suede tend to show depth and natural variation, while synthetics can look flatter.
  • Structure matters: a splurge often holds its shape, while a dupe's shaft or collar can look softer.
  • Check the small stuff: toe shape, sole edge and stitching lines are where lookalikes drift.

Questions, answered

How does Spot the Splurge work?

You see two photos with brands and prices hidden. Tap the one you think is the designer piece. Then we reveal the answer, the tells and the live prices.

How were these pieces picked?

We chose well-known designer styles and affordable lookalikes. We compare using listings and photos, so some details, like materials or hardware, may not be confirmed.

Brand names are used only to describe what each dupe is inspired by. #dupe isn't affiliated with the brands mentioned. Prices and stock change; check the store before you buy.

Know someone who'd love these finds?