Coach Brooklyn Shoulder Bag The original

#dupe isn't affiliated with or endorsed by Coach.

Brooklyn Shoulder Bag

A slouchy hobo-style shoulder bag with a soft, rounded body that sags casually when carried. It is made from smooth leather, closes with a magnetic snap, and hangs from a short shoulder strap. It comes in two sizes, both roomy enough for daily use.

Original
$450
Dupes from
$28.90
Save up to
94%
See all 3 dupes ↓
View the original at coach.com ↗ (opens new tab)

Affiliate links. Prices change, so check the store for the latest.

The dupes

  1. Dupe Score 8/10 Save 94%

    Hoxis Vegan Leather Slouchy Bag

    The Hoxis bag gets the same relaxed, slouchy black hobo look as the Coach Brooklyn for a fraction of the price, but it has a pebbled faux leather finish and none of the gold hardware or charm.

    What's the same, what's not
    • Shape: a soft, slouchy hobo body that widens toward the base and sags when carried
    • Shape: a single short, rounded shoulder strap that flows straight into the sides of the bag
    • Color and finish: solid black all over with a minimal, logo-light front
    • Signature detail: a small stamp or plate centered below the neckline, a spot where Coach has its logo
    • Size: roomy for daily use, with the Hoxis listed at about 18 x 15.7 x 4.7 inches; the Coach's exact dimensions are not stated here
    • Material: smooth leather on the Coach; the Hoxis is vegan (faux) leather with a visible pebbled grain, so it looks more textured and glossier
    • Missing details: no gold clasp or hanging leather tag charm on the side, and the neckline is a rounded scoop rather than the Coach's sharper V-shaped dip
    • Construction: the Hoxis strap looks thinner and more tubular, and the closure is not stated in the listing, whereas the Coach closes with a magnetic snap
    • Durability: faux leather will likely not age or hold its shape like real leather

    Report an issue

    Side by side · Dupe 1 of 3

    Coach Brooklyn Shoulder Bag vs Hoxis Vegan Leather Slouchy Bag

    Coach Brooklyn Shoulder Bag The original

    Coach

    Brooklyn Shoulder Bag

    $450

    #dupe isn't affiliated with or endorsed by Coach.

    View at coach.com ↗ (opens new tab)
    Hoxis Vegan Leather Slouchy Bag The dupe

    Hoxis

    Hoxis Vegan Leather Slouchy Bag

    $28.90 Save 94%

    Shop at Amazon (opens store)
    $450
    Price
    $28.90
     
    You save
    $421.10 (94%)
    Dupe Score
    8/10
    coach.com
    Sold at
    Amazon +1 more

    The Hoxis bag gets the same relaxed, slouchy black hobo look as the Coach Brooklyn for a fraction of the price, but it has a pebbled faux leather finish and none of the gold hardware or charm.

    • Shape: a soft, slouchy hobo body that widens toward the base and sags when carried
    • Shape: a single short, rounded shoulder strap that flows straight into the sides of the bag
    • Color and finish: solid black all over with a minimal, logo-light front
    • Signature detail: a small stamp or plate centered below the neckline, a spot where Coach has its logo
    • Size: roomy for daily use, with the Hoxis listed at about 18 x 15.7 x 4.7 inches; the Coach's exact dimensions are not stated here
    • Material: smooth leather on the Coach; the Hoxis is vegan (faux) leather with a visible pebbled grain, so it looks more textured and glossier
    • Missing details: no gold clasp or hanging leather tag charm on the side, and the neckline is a rounded scoop rather than the Coach's sharper V-shaped dip
    • Construction: the Hoxis strap looks thinner and more tubular, and the closure is not stated in the listing, whereas the Coach closes with a magnetic snap
    • Durability: faux leather will likely not age or hold its shape like real leather
  2. Dupe Score 7/10 Save 87%

    befen Slouchy Leather Hobo Bag

    The befen hobo has the same slouchy, sagging shoulder-bag shape and a plain black look, so it's worth a look if you want that relaxed silhouette for a fraction of the price, though it drops Coach's branding and hang tag.

    What's the same, what's not
    • Shape: a soft, unstructured hobo body that sags and gathers at the bottom, with sides that slope up to a single strap
    • Shape: a one-piece, arched shoulder strap that rises from the sides in a tall loop and has no separate handle
    • Color and finish: solid black all over with no contrast trim or prints, so the bag reads as minimal and monochrome
    • Size: a roomy, wide body that carries as a daily-use shoulder bag, though the dupe's exact dimensions are not stated
    • Material: smooth leather on the original; the dupe's title says leather but its listing details were not readable, so the exact type is not stated, and the photo shows a pebbled grain rather than a smooth one
    • Missing details: no Coach logo stamp, and no leather hang tag with gold clasp on the strap side
    • Hardware: the original uses a magnetic snap and gold-tone hardware; the dupe appears to have a center zip with two leather pulls and silver-tone metal
    • Construction: the original has a V-shaped neckline, while the dupe has a deeper, rounded scoop; stitching and lining details are not stated

    Report an issue

    Side by side · Dupe 2 of 3

    Coach Brooklyn Shoulder Bag vs befen Slouchy Leather Hobo Bag

    Coach Brooklyn Shoulder Bag The original

    Coach

    Brooklyn Shoulder Bag

    $450

    #dupe isn't affiliated with or endorsed by Coach.

    View at coach.com ↗ (opens new tab)
    befen Slouchy Leather Hobo Bag The dupe

    befen

    befen Slouchy Leather Hobo Bag

    $59.99 Save 87%

    Shop at Amazon (opens store)
    $450
    Price
    $59.99
     
    You save
    $390.01 (87%)
    Dupe Score
    7/10
    coach.com
    Sold at
    Amazon

    The befen hobo has the same slouchy, sagging shoulder-bag shape and a plain black look, so it's worth a look if you want that relaxed silhouette for a fraction of the price, though it drops Coach's branding and hang tag.

    • Shape: a soft, unstructured hobo body that sags and gathers at the bottom, with sides that slope up to a single strap
    • Shape: a one-piece, arched shoulder strap that rises from the sides in a tall loop and has no separate handle
    • Color and finish: solid black all over with no contrast trim or prints, so the bag reads as minimal and monochrome
    • Size: a roomy, wide body that carries as a daily-use shoulder bag, though the dupe's exact dimensions are not stated
    • Material: smooth leather on the original; the dupe's title says leather but its listing details were not readable, so the exact type is not stated, and the photo shows a pebbled grain rather than a smooth one
    • Missing details: no Coach logo stamp, and no leather hang tag with gold clasp on the strap side
    • Hardware: the original uses a magnetic snap and gold-tone hardware; the dupe appears to have a center zip with two leather pulls and silver-tone metal
    • Construction: the original has a V-shaped neckline, while the dupe has a deeper, rounded scoop; stitching and lining details are not stated
  3. Dupe Score 6/10 Save 88%

    Morriloom Leather Hobo Bag

    This black leather hobo has the same slouchy, single-strap shoulder-bag shape as the Coach Brooklyn and comes in genuine leather for a fraction of the price. The compromise is a busier design with zips and seams, and it has none of Coach's branding.

    What's the same, what's not
    • Shape: a soft, slouchy hobo body that sags and tapers from a wide base to a narrower top
    • Signature detail: one continuous shoulder strap that rises from the body in a single loop with no buckles along its length
    • Color and finish: solid black with a soft, supple leather look and no pattern or print
    • Size: both are roomy, everyday-sized shoulder bags that hang from a short drop strap
    • Material: smooth Coach leather on the original; the dupe's listing says genuine leather with a nylon lining
    • Construction: the original has a clean, seamless front and a magnetic snap. The dupe has a zipper closure, visible topstitched panel seams and a side zip detail, so it looks more utilitarian.
    • Missing details: no V-shaped neckline, no Coach logo stamp and no leather hangtag with gold clasp. The dupe uses silver-toned hardware, and its asymmetric curved top opening looks different from the original's V-cut.
    • Size or fit: exact dimensions for this listing are not stated, and it comes with a second strap, so it can be worn as a crossbody

    Report an issue

    Side by side · Dupe 3 of 3

    Coach Brooklyn Shoulder Bag vs Morriloom Leather Hobo Bag

    Coach Brooklyn Shoulder Bag The original

    Coach

    Brooklyn Shoulder Bag

    $450

    #dupe isn't affiliated with or endorsed by Coach.

    View at coach.com ↗ (opens new tab)
    Morriloom Leather Hobo Bag The dupe

    Morriloom

    Morriloom Leather Hobo Bag

    $55 Save 88%

    Shop at Amazon (opens store)
    $450
    Price
    $55
     
    You save
    $395 (88%)
    Dupe Score
    6/10
    coach.com
    Sold at
    Amazon

    This black leather hobo has the same slouchy, single-strap shoulder-bag shape as the Coach Brooklyn and comes in genuine leather for a fraction of the price. The compromise is a busier design with zips and seams, and it has none of Coach's branding.

    • Shape: a soft, slouchy hobo body that sags and tapers from a wide base to a narrower top
    • Signature detail: one continuous shoulder strap that rises from the body in a single loop with no buckles along its length
    • Color and finish: solid black with a soft, supple leather look and no pattern or print
    • Size: both are roomy, everyday-sized shoulder bags that hang from a short drop strap
    • Material: smooth Coach leather on the original; the dupe's listing says genuine leather with a nylon lining
    • Construction: the original has a clean, seamless front and a magnetic snap. The dupe has a zipper closure, visible topstitched panel seams and a side zip detail, so it looks more utilitarian.
    • Missing details: no V-shaped neckline, no Coach logo stamp and no leather hangtag with gold clasp. The dupe uses silver-toned hardware, and its asymmetric curved top opening looks different from the original's V-cut.
    • Size or fit: exact dimensions for this listing are not stated, and it comes with a second strap, so it can be worn as a crossbody

#dupe isn't affiliated with or endorsed by Coach. These are independent comparisons of similar-looking products, not claims that they are identical.

Dupe
Battle

Inspired by the Coach Brooklyn Shoulder Bag · $450

Two dupes, one look. Which looks closest to the original?

Coach Brooklyn Shoulder Bag The originalCoach Brooklyn Shoulder Bag

More battles → See the full lineup →
Hoxis Vegan Leather Slouchy Bag

Dupe A

Hoxis Vegan Leather Slouchy Bag

$28.90 at Amazon

befen Slouchy Leather Hobo Bag

Dupe B

befen Slouchy Leather Hobo Bag

$59.99 at Amazon