Dupe Market Weekly: Christmas Gift Shoppers Reach for Dupes

UK data shows dupes moving into holiday gifting, Quince keeps expanding, and a retailer drops its suit over comparison ads.

Dupes are moving into the Christmas gift aisle. Retail Gazette reports new YPulse research finding that 44 per cent of UK consumers aged 13 to 39 bought a dupe in the past year. The Guardian, in a piece syndicated by AOL, compares a £95 White Company candle with an Aldi version at £25.

By the numbers

UK gifting data points one way. In the same YPulse research, 53 per cent of respondents said the quality of cheaper alternatives made them less likely to buy the original luxury product, according to Retail Gazette. It also cites NielsenIQ: 38 per cent of UK consumers switched to lower-priced brands over the past year, and the number buying dupe fragrances online rose 17 per cent year on year. NielsenIQ adds that millennials, not only Gen Z, account for the biggest share of dupe sales.

A price gap shoppers can see. Retail Gazette reports that Zara's £15.99 Violet Blossom fragrance is being promoted by TikTok users as a cheaper alternative to Mugler's Alien, which costs almost £130. Premium is not dead, though. Research from Savvy Marketing, cited in the same piece, suggests nearly 80 per cent of shoppers will still pay more for occasional luxuries when the quality justifies it.

US shoppers report real savings. A CardRates survey of 1,000 people, published within the past month, found 47% of Gen Z respondents had bought dupes. Among respondents who bought dupes, 65% estimated they saved at least $100 over the previous year. These are self-reported figures from one survey, and 15% of all respondents also said they had gone into debt buying an expensive original.

Money moves

Quince takes its model abroad. Retail Gazette reported last month that Quince launched in the UK, its first market beyond the US and Canada. The outlet says Quince generated more than $1 billion in revenue in 2025 and claims 32 million monthly users across North America. It also reports a $500 million raise in March at a $10.1 billion valuation. These are reported figures and company claims.

Earnings week tests the value shopper. According to Invezz, Target reports on Wednesday, November 18, and Walmart on Thursday, November 19. The article says lower-income shoppers are switching to cheaper brands, which it calls Walmart's core strength. EBC notes Walmart plans to put tariff refunds into pricing and customer experience in the second half of the year. We will cover the results next week.

In court

This is news and commentary, not legal advice. The items below are from the past 30 days or older, because nothing new was decided in the past seven.

Williams-Sonoma drops its suit against Quince. Bloomberg Law reported on November 4 that Williams-Sonoma voluntarily dismissed its false advertising case without prejudice, rather than amend its complaint. A month earlier, Judge Edward J. Davila had dismissed the suit with leave to amend. He found Williams-Sonoma had not sufficiently alleged that Quince's ads calling items "like" its goods, or its comparison charts, were false or misleading. Reuters (via TradingView) identifies the case as Williams-Sonoma Inc v. Last Brand Inc d/b/a Quince. The line here: naming the original in a comparison is not enough to make an ad false. Because the dismissal was without prejudice, the claim could in theory return.

Lululemon and Costco end without a ruling. Mondaq says the case was terminated in August 2026 on undisclosed terms, with no judicial decision on the merits. So the biggest US dupe case produced no precedent on where the line sits.

Functional packaging stays open to all. World Trademark Review reports that a New York court ruled Sol de Janeiro's Bum Bum Cream packaging cannot receive trade dress protection because its features are functional. The Michigan Undergraduate Law Review calls it the latest in a series of brands suing dupe sellers and failing to prevail. Looks and shapes that serve a purpose are hard to own, while misleading claims remain a separate risk.

How brands are responding

Justifying the price. Retail Gazette says luxury retailers must increasingly justify higher prices as cheaper competitors gain traction. The Guardian quotes NielsenIQ's Eric Mills on the challenge for top brands such as Charlotte Tilbury: convincing shoppers the quality difference is worth paying for.

Joining the conversation. Mondaq notes that Lululemon registered "LULULEMON DUPE" as a trademark for Class 35 services. Brands are using IP to shape the dupe conversation as well as to sue.

What it means

For shoppers, the gift season brings more side-by-side choices, and the data points to real savings when you compare carefully. For the market, the signals this week are consistent: dupe demand is reaching more ages and categories, and the legal picture favors fair comparison over copied logos or misleading claims. Businesses that are open about what they are, and honest in their ads, look best placed. Premium brands still hold shoppers who see the quality, which keeps the competition focused on value.

The takeaways

  • UK research reported this week finds 44% of 13-to-39-year-olds bought a dupe in the past year, as dupes enter Christmas gifting.
  • NielsenIQ reports dupe fragrance buyers online up 17% year on year, with millennials the biggest share of dupe sales.
  • Williams-Sonoma dropped its false advertising suit against Quince after a judge found the claims insufficiently alleged.
  • The Lululemon-Costco case ended without a ruling, so no new precedent was set.
  • Target and Walmart report earnings November 18 and 19, a test of how value-seeking shoppers are behaving.

Questions, answered

Are dupes legal?

Generally, a lower-priced product that looks similar can be legal, while copying a logo or misleading shoppers is not. Recent rulings, such as the one denying trade dress protection for Sol de Janeiro's packaging, show functional designs are hard to protect. This is general information, not legal advice.

How many shoppers buy dupes?

It depends on the survey. YPulse found 44% of UK consumers aged 13 to 39 bought a dupe in the past year, and a CardRates survey of 1,000 people found 47% of Gen Z respondents had bought dupes.

Do dupes actually save shoppers money?

In the CardRates survey, 65% of respondents who bought dupes estimated they saved at least $100 over the previous year. That is self-reported, and individual savings vary.

Sources

  1. Retail Gazette

    Nov. 16, 2026. YPulse: 44 per cent of UK consumers aged 13 to 39 bought a dupe in the past year; 53 per cent said the quality of cheaper alternatives made them less likely to buy the original luxury product. NielsenIQ: 38 per cent switched to lower-priced brands, dupe fragrance buyers online up 17 per cent year on year, millennials the biggest share of dupe sales. Zara £15.99 vs Mugler Alien at al

  2. The Guardian (via AOL)

    Nov. 15, 2026. The White Company candle at £95 vs Aldi's dupe at £25; NielsenIQ's Eric Mills on the challenge for top brands like Charlotte Tilbury of convincing shoppers the quality difference is worth paying for.

  3. CardRates.com

    Survey of 1,000 people: 47% of Gen Z respondents bought dupes; among dupe buyers, 65% estimated saving at least $100 over the previous year; 15% of respondents reported going into debt from buying an expensive original.

  4. Retail Gazette (Quince UK launch)

    Quince launched in the UK, its first market beyond the US and Canada; more than $1 billion revenue in 2025 and claims 32 million monthly users; $500 million raised in March at a $10.1 billion valuation.

  5. Invezz

    Target reports Nov. 18 and Walmart Nov. 19; says lower-income shoppers are switching to cheaper brands, which is Walmart's core strength.

  6. EBC

    Walmart plans to reinvest tariff refunds in pricing and customer experience in the second half of 2026; earnings release on Nov. 19.

  7. Bloomberg Law

    Nov. 4, 2026. Williams-Sonoma voluntarily dismissed its suit without prejudice instead of amending; a month earlier Judge Edward J. Davila dismissed it with leave to amend because it failed to sufficiently allege Quince's "like" ads and comparison charts were false or misleading.

  8. Reuters (via TradingView)

    Williams-Sonoma asked a California federal court to dismiss its lawsuit against Quince; case is Williams-Sonoma Inc v. Last Brand Inc d/b/a Quince, N.D. Cal.

  9. Mondaq

    Lululemon v. Costco was terminated in August 2026 on undisclosed terms, without a judicial decision on the merits; also notes Lululemon's registration of LULULEMON DUPE (International Class 35).

  10. World Trademark Review

    Headline summary: Sol de Janeiro's Bum Bum Cream packaging cannot receive trade dress protection because its features are functional, a New York court has ruled.

  11. Michigan Undergraduate Law Review

    Describes the Sol de Janeiro ruling as the latest in a series of brands suing and failing to prevail against dupe sellers.

Sources checked on November 17, 2026.

Brand names are used only to describe what each dupe is inspired by. #dupe isn't affiliated with the brands mentioned. Prices and stock change; check the store before you buy.

Know someone who'd love these finds?