Spot the Splurge: Can You Pick the Designer Shoes?

Five designer shoes, five lookalikes, one question each: which is the splurge? Look closely and make your call.

We compare dupes side by side from listings and photos. Some links earn us a small commission at no cost to you; it never decides what we pick. How that works.

Welcome to Spot the Splurge! Each round shows two shoes with brands and prices hidden. Look closely, then tap the one you think is the designer piece. Today's theme is shoes: strappy sandals, a woven flat, two sculptural boots and a glossy pump. We start easy and get sneakier.

Round 1 of 5

Which one is the splurge?

Hint Look at the stitching on the straps.

Just show me the answer

The splurge · Option B

Balmain Smooth Leather Cage Sandals

$1,095

The dupe · Option A

OMLISHZTY Caged Slingback Kitten Heel Sandals

$39.99 Save 96%

The splurge is the Balmain Smooth Leather Cage Sandal, made in Italy with smooth, clean strap work and a single ankle strap. The dupe gives itself away with visibly top-stitched straps, plus an extra T-strap and a slingback-style strap. The tradeoff: it's listed as a kitten heel, so it may sit lower than the original's 9.5cm stiletto.

Round 2 of 5

Which one is the splurge?

Hint Zoom in on the gold bar near the top of the shaft.

Just show me the answer

The splurge · Option B

Givenchy Shark Pinch Boots

$2,550

The dupe · Option A

Yishaweiqi Black Fold Over Knee High Boots

$57 Save 98%

The splurge is the Givenchy Shark Pinch Boot, with a calfskin shaft and a gold pinch bar engraved with the house name. The dupe's bar looks plain in the photo, and its material isn't stated, so it's likely synthetic. The tradeoff: shaft height, opening width and heel height aren't listed, so the fit may differ.

Round 3 of 5

Which one is the splurge?

Hint Check the toe peeking out under the folded flap.

Just show me the answer

The splurge · Option A

Givenchy Shark Pinch Ankle Boots

$2,120

The dupe · Option B

Kluolandi Women's Fold Over Wedge Boots

$60 Save 97%

The splurge is the Givenchy Shark Pinch Ankle Boot, with calfskin, a sharper point at the toe and engraved lettering on its gold bar. The dupe's toe looks slightly rounder and its bar has no engraving. The tradeoff: the fold-over flap and strap look looser and less structured, with a less refined edge finish.

Round 4 of 5

Which one is the splurge?

Hint Check what crosses the front of the foot.

Just show me the answer

The splurge · Option A

Yves Saint Laurent Brigitte Pumps

$3,600

The dupe · Option B

OMLISHZTY Jelly Stiletto Point Toe Pump

$40 Save 99%

The splurge is the Yves Saint Laurent Brigitte Pump, with a TPU body, a patent strap across the vamp, tiny vent holes and an angled metal heel. We couldn't confirm any of those details on the dupe, which is likely a mass-made jelly shoe with a lighter heel. The tradeoff: its material isn't stated, and jelly-style uppers usually flex and scuff more.

Round 5 of 5

Which one is the splurge?

Hint Study the weave and the shape of the toe.

Just show me the answer

The splurge · Option A

Loeffler Randall Emery Ballet Flat

$350

The dupe · Option B

OMLISHZTY Woven Leather Ballet Flats Mary Jane

$45.99 Save 87%

The splurge is the Loeffler Randall Emery Ballet Flat, with a hand-braided, open cane-style leather weave, a removable crystal ankle strap and a gold-stamped logo footbed. The dupe is listed as woven with a glossy finish, but the listing gives few details. The tradeoff: its material isn't stated and is likely faux leather, and the weave density and toe shape are unknown.

How to shop this look

  • Check the stitching. Visible top-stitching on straps can signal simpler construction.
  • Look at the hardware. Engraved lettering and crisp, polished metal often point to the splurge.
  • Study the edges and structure. Clean edges and shapes that hold their form usually cost more.
  • Watch the sheen. A satin or plasticky gloss can mean a synthetic upper.

Questions, answered

How does the game work?

You see two photos with brands and prices hidden. Tap the one you think is the designer piece. Then we reveal the answer, the tells and the live prices.

How were the pairs picked?

We compared each designer piece with a lookalike using product listings and photos. We never claim to have tested anything. Where a listing doesn't state a detail, we say so.

Brand names are used only to describe what each dupe is inspired by. #dupe isn't affiliated with the brands mentioned. Prices and stock change; check the store before you buy.

Know someone who'd love these finds?